Anti avoidance provisions under the Treaty v Specific anti-avoidance provisions under Tax treaty

CA Pilar Shivanand Nayak & CA Bibhuti Ram Krishna
INTRODUCTION
Conceptually, the phenomenon of ‘abuse of tax laws’ is very challenging and complex. The toughest
task is to classify an act or purpose of a transaction as ‘use’ or ‘abuse’ of law. The
mitigation in tax outflow can be out of use or abuse of law. To identify and categorize the actions into one of
them could often be tough.
An attempt to ease or clarify this classification has paved way for enactment/ introduction of several rules,
regulations and provisions. The over legislation to counter and combat the possibility of abuse of law results
in overlap amongst the various statutes. The objective in this write-up is also to understand one such tussle
between the anti-abuse provisions in the tax treaty context.
Anti-abuse provisions in the treaty
.......